Shortly earlier than 7 p.m. Tuesday, a volley of rockets lit up the darkened sky over Gaza. Movies analyzed by The Related Press present one veering off beam, breaking apart within the air earlier than crashing to the bottom.
Seconds later, the movies present a big explosion in the identical space – the location of Gaza’s al-Ahli Arab Hospital.
Who’s guilty for the fiery explosion has set off intense debate and finger pointing between the Israeli authorities and Palestinian militants, additional escalating tensions of their two week-long struggle.
The AP analyzed greater than a dozen movies from the moments earlier than, throughout and after the hospital explosion, in addition to satellite tv for pc imagery and images. AP’s evaluation reveals that the rocket that broke up within the air was fired from inside Palestinian territory, and that the hospital explosion was more than likely brought about when a part of that rocket crashed to the bottom.
An absence of forensic proof and the problem of gathering that materials on the bottom in the midst of a struggle means there isn’t any definitive proof the break-up of the rocket and the explosion on the hospital are linked. Nonetheless, AP’s evaluation is supported by a spread of consultants with specialties in open-source intelligence, geolocation and rocketry.
“Within the absence of further proof, the more than likely situation can be that it was a rocket launched from Gaza that failed mid-flight and that it mistakenly hit the hospital,” mentioned Henry Schlottman, a former U.S. Military intelligence analyst and open-source intelligence knowledgeable.
The AP reached its conclusion by reviewing greater than a dozen movies from information broadcasts, safety cameras and social media posts, and matching the areas to satellite tv for pc imagery and images from earlier than the explosion.
A key video within the evaluation got here shortly earlier than 7 p.m. native time, when the Arabic-language information channel Al Jazeera was airing stay protection of the Gaza Metropolis skyline. As a correspondent speaks, the digital camera pans to zoom in on a volley of rockets being fired from the bottom close by.
One of many rockets seems to veer from the others, away from the distant lights of Israel and again towards a darkened Gaza Metropolis, the place electrical energy has largely been minimize. The digital camera follows the sunshine from the rocket’s tail because it arches within the sky upwards and towards the left. Instantly, the rocket appears to fragment, and a chunk seems to interrupt off and fall. One other fragment shoots sharply up and to the best, blazing earlier than it explodes in a fireworks-like flash, leaving a quick path of sparks.
A small explosion is then seen on the bottom within the distance, adopted two seconds later by a a lot bigger blast nearer to the digital camera. The nook of the scroll on the backside of the stay broadcast reads 6:59 p.m. Gaza time.
Utilizing maps and satellite tv for pc imagery, the AP was capable of match the view of the explosion from Al Jazeera’s stay digital camera feed to an higher ground of the constructing that homes Al Jazeera’s Gaza bureau, which is lower than a mile (1.5 kilometers) from the al-Ahli Arab Hospital. Utilizing different buildings seen within the body, the AP was capable of verify that the bigger explosion seen at 6:59 p.m. was within the exact path of the hospital.
A second video, taken from a digital camera inside Israel on the precise time because the Al Jazeera footage and obtained by the AP, reveals a barrage of at the very least 17 rockets being launched from inside Gaza earlier than a big explosion lights up the horizon on the Palestinian facet of the border. The digital camera is on a constructing in Netiv Ha’asara, an Israeli neighborhood footsteps from the border wall, and faces southwest, confirming that the rocket launches and explosion had been within the path of Gaza Metropolis.
A 3rd video by Israeli information station Channel 12 — taken from a digital camera on the higher ground of its constructing in Netivot, a city about 10 miles (16 kilometers) southeast of the hospital in Gaza Metropolis — additionally captured the barrage of rockets fired at 6:59 p.m.
Seen collectively, the three movies present a number of rockets had been launched from inside Gaza earlier than one seems to have come aside in midair about three seconds earlier than the explosion on the al-Ahli Arab Hospital.
At 7 p.m., one minute after the explosion, Hamas’ navy wing al-Qassam Brigades mentioned in a submit to its Telegram channel that it “fired at occupied Ashdod with a barrage of rockets.” Ashdod is an Israeli coastal metropolis about 30 miles (50 kilometers) north of Gaza.
Minutes later, Islamic Jihad, a militant group that works with Hamas, additionally posted on Telegram that it had launched a rocket strike on Tel Aviv in response “to bloodbath towards civilians.” Over the subsequent hour, there have been 5 extra posts from the militant teams asserting rocket assaults towards Israel.
Israel’s navy has repeatedly mentioned it didn’t strike the hospital and blamed an errant rocket fired from inside Gaza by the Islamic Jihad. Israel’s evaluation, backed by U.S. intelligence and President Joe Biden, additionally cited the dearth of each a big crater and in depth structural harm that may be in step with a bomb dropped by Israeli plane.
Hamas calls Israel’s narrative “fabricated” and accuses it of punishing the hospital for ignoring a warning to evacuate two days earlier, although it has not launched any proof to assist its claims.
Hamas spokesperson Ghazi Hamad instructed the AP the group would welcome a United Nations investigation into the reason for the blast.
“Take a look at the silly place that was taken by the President of the USA of America who mentioned, ‘I agree with Israel’s model’ with none investigation,” Hamad mentioned. “Sadly, the Western world is stuffed with hypocrisy.”
AP ran its visible evaluation by a half-dozen consultants who all agreed the more than likely situation was a rocket from inside Gaza that veered off and got here aside seconds earlier than the explosion.
Andrea Richardson, an knowledgeable in analyzing open-source intelligence who’s a guide with the Human Rights Heart on the College of California, Berkeley, College of Legislation, mentioned particular landmarks seen within the movies present the place the rockets had been launched.
“From the video proof that I’ve seen, it’s very clear that the rockets got here from inside Gaza,” mentioned Richardson, a human rights lawyer and skilled struggle crimes investigator who has labored within the Center East. She added that the timing of the rocket launches, the explosion and the primary stories that the hospital had been hit additionally appeared to substantiate the sequence of occasions.
Whereas nonetheless doubtlessly deadly, the explosive warheads carried by the selfmade rockets utilized by militants in Gaza will be comparatively small when put next with the munitions utilized by massive militaries like these of the U.S. and Russia. With Gaza’s borders and ports blockaded for the previous decade, the militants typically construct rockets inside Gaza utilizing no matter elements and supplies they will scavenge, together with underground water pipes.
Justin Crump, a former British Military officer and intelligence guide, mentioned the failure fee of such selfmade rockets is excessive.
“You possibly can see clearly it fails in flight, it spins out and disintegrates, and the impacts on the bottom comply with that,” mentioned Crump, CEO of Skyline, a London-based strategic advisory agency. “The more than likely rationalization is that this was a tragic accident.”
Such a situation unfolded final 12 months, when Islamic Jihad-fired rockets malfunctioned and killed at the very least a dozen Gaza residents. The AP reported on the time that stay TV footage confirmed the militant rockets falling brief in densely packed residential neighborhoods.
A number of the questions on who’s guilty deal with the three-second hole between the rocket’s explosive breakup within the sky and the explosion on the bottom on the al-Ahli Arab Hospital, and whether or not these two occasions are linked, particularly as a result of the movies analyzed by AP don’t seem to indicate a hint of sunshine that follows the rocket to the bottom.
Exterior consultants mentioned it isn’t potential to rule out with absolute certainty that the rocket launches occurring close to the hospital and the timing of the explosion seconds later are only a coincidence. Nonetheless, additionally they famous there isn’t any proof to assist that situation.
Richardson mentioned the timestamps on movies displaying the rocket launches from inside Gaza, the midair malfunction and the big explosion hanging the hospital under inside seconds of one another offered a logical chain of occasions.
“An extremely small timeframe,” she mentioned.
Intelligence analyst Schlottman mentioned the more than likely situation stays that it was a militant rocket that someway had some type of malfunction mid-flight after which landed on the hospital.
“We now have video of when the explosion occurred and the one rocket seen in that video was the one which type of had that diverging trajectory,” he mentioned. “We can’t probably exclude different situations. … Simply what we now have proper now factors to that.”
About 10 minutes after the a number of rocket launches from Gaza had been captured on video Tuesday night time, posts started to appear on social media. The AP verified a video taken from a balcony close to the hospital that reveals the second of influence, with the loud whizzing sound adopted by an enormous fireball and the clap of an enormous explosion. AP might discover no visible proof to assist hypothesis that the blast was triggered by a automotive bomb or different such machine.
“Oh God! Oh God!” a person’s voice exclaims in Arabic. “The hospital!” says a second male voice.
Different movies and images reviewed by AP seem to indicate the explosion within the hospital’s central parking zone and courtyard, the place civilians had taken refuge after orders to evacuate the town. Some footage reveals burning vehicles and greater than a dozen {dead} our bodies, together with these of youngsters.
AP images taken the morning after Tuesday’s explosion confirmed no proof of a big crater on the influence website that may be in step with a bomb like these dropped by Israeli plane in different latest strikes. The hospital buildings surrounding the outside space on the middle of the explosion had been nonetheless standing and didn’t seem to endure vital structural harm.
A small crater photographed within the hospital’s parking zone gave the impression to be a couple of meter throughout, suggesting a tool with a a lot smaller explosive payload than a bomb. Whereas Israel’s in depth arsenal consists of smaller missiles that may be fired from helicopters and drones, there was no public proof of such missile strikes within the space across the al-Ahli Arab Hospital on Tuesday night time.
David Shank, a retired U.S. Military colonel and knowledgeable on navy rockets and missiles, mentioned the big fireball captured on video on the hospital might doubtlessly be defined by the actual fact the malfunctioning militant rocket impacted prematurely and was nonetheless filled with propellant. That extremely unstable gasoline then ignited when it hit the bottom, setting off a big explosion however leaving a comparatively small crater.
After Hamas’ Oct. 7 shock assault on southern Israel that killed 1,400, with one other 200 individuals taken hostage, Israel’s navy mentioned it dropped greater than 6,000 bombs on Gaza within the first week of the struggle alone, and Gaza officers say that marketing campaign has to date resulted in additional than 4,100 deaths.
Hamas spokesman Hamad mentioned that Israeli officers had threatened al-Ahli Arab hospital and different medical services, and ordered their evacuation earlier than the lethal blast. He argued that the missiles belonging to Hamas and the Islamic Jihad wouldn’t have been able to inflicting such harm.
Al-Ahli Arab Hospital’s operators posted on its web site that the power’s most cancers middle was struck by Israel three days earlier than the lethal blast, leaving a gap in an exterior wall and an unexploded artillery shell subsequent to an ultrasound machine.
Hypothesis has circulated on social media within the days because the explosion that the breakup of the rocket and the explosion on the bottom was attributable to Israel’s Iron Dome protection system, which is designed to shoot such rockets out of the sky.
Israel has mentioned it doesn’t use its Iron Dome system inside Gaza, however to intercept and destroy rockets coming into Israeli airspace.
Consultants additionally famous a number of movies from across the time of the hospital explosion confirmed no seen proof of Iron Dome missiles being fired from Israel into the airspace over Gaza.
John Erath, the senior coverage director on the Heart for Arms Management and an knowledgeable on missile protection, mentioned that whereas it is perhaps technically potential for Iron Dome to intercept a missile over Gaza, it could be unlikely on this case as a result of the projectile was very early in its flight path – nonetheless on the best way up – and the system is designed to solely intercept projectiles it determines are on a flight path to a populated a part of Israel.
“I’m not saying that it’s unimaginable,” Erath mentioned. “However based mostly on my understanding of how the system works, it’s unlikely.”
Added missile knowledgeable Shank: “They don’t have interaction a goal until it’s going to influence a vital asset akin to a inhabitants space, possibly an influence grid, possibly a navy base.”
“It’s technically designed to take the perfect shot that provides it the very best chance of kill,” he mentioned. “And for Iron Dome … that isn’t over Gaza.”
___
AP International Investigative Reporter Michael Biesecker reported from Washington. Reporter Danica Kirka in London contributed.
__
Contact AP’s world investigative staff at Investigative@ap.org.