You pissed off folks by somewhat breaking your app, and so they’re leaving indignant critiques. How are you going to salvage your status? Apple simply discovered one extremely efficient manner — get listeners to submit higher critiques by interrupting their podcast expertise with an in-app immediate to submit a score.
That’s how the Apple Podcasts app went from a publicly embarrassing 1.8-star rating all the way in which to 4.6 stars in a bit over a month with none precise fixes, as developer and App Retailer watchdog Kosta Eleftheriou points out. And it’s nonetheless going up: in accordance with AppFigures data, the app has been getting 1000’s of rankings day-after-day since November ninth, with the huge, overwhelming majority of them issuing a 5-star rating.
The app has made it to 4.7 stars total as of this writing and is firmly the No. 1 App Retailer search end result for “podcast.” It appears much more fascinating to a brand new person than it might need earlier than.
If you happen to suppose there’s a superbly cheap rationalization for this, you may be proper — it may undoubtedly be that individuals who hassle to submit critiques are usually indignant, and lots of people who love Apple Podcasts and by no means bothered to look it up within the App Retailer (keep in mind, it’s preinstalled!) are lastly balancing issues out.
However do these folks truly love Apple Podcasts? As a result of if you happen to actually have a look at the critiques, it looks like some humorous enterprise is happening. There are new, Positive critiques, however they aren’t critiques of the Apple Podcasts app in any respect — they’re critiques of podcasts themselves.
I child you not — that is the highest evaluate for Apple Podcasts on the App Retailer:
Listed below are a couple of extra of the “Most Latest” critiques of the Apple Podcasts app:
- “Wonderful present! Hilarious and effectively researched,” writes SammyAls, including, “The dynamic is wonderful, and the content material is SO wanted! Love this.”
- “Mobley has Depth and Perception,” writes xbacksideslider. “Good to take heed to considerate and factual podcast. Removed from the superficial emotional appeals to envy and self congratulating fake empathy that so dominate in style tradition.”
- “The desk,” says Jkimble6091. “Being a future younger millionaire listening to Anthony Oneal retains me on monitor throughout all of the ups and downs of life.”
I questioned if perhaps this was a standard confusion with podcast apps, the place listeners suppose they’re reviewing a podcast as a substitute of the app itself. However no, I didn’t see that apparent sample once I checked critiques for different high podcast apps within the App Retailer. Virtually each evaluate on competing apps was a evaluate of the apps themselves.
Apple confirmed to The Verge that it’s utilizing a brand new immediate however claims it’s nothing out of the unusual. “With iOS 15.1 launched final month, Apple Podcasts started prompting listeners to depart a score and evaluate identical to most third-party apps — utilizing the usual Score & Evaluate immediate accessible to all builders,” a spokesperson tells us.
We weren’t in a position to monitor down a replica of the immediate ourselves to verify when and the place it seems or what it appears like — which appears vital if persons are getting confused — however it’s certainly a standard feature of the App Store, one you may even flip off if you happen to like underneath Settings > App Retailer > In-App Rankings & Critiques.
However intentional or not, normal or not, the issue with star scores is there’s no solution to inform whether or not they’re respectable. We don’t know if somebody pressed a five-star button as a result of they liked the app, or thought they have been score the podcast itself, or simply wished to shut the immediate as shortly as potential. We don’t know if Apple is prompting everybody, or simply its most devoted followers, or another algorithmic subset that just happened to give it an advantage. Some dangerous actors reportedly even purchase star scores for their egregious App Store scams, and it’s not possible for many App Retailer customers to inform. We’ve even seen an iOS app that refuses to open unless you give it a good score.
These are the the explanation why I steered that Apple should lead the industry by killing off star ratings for good, amongst different issues it may do to show it places folks forward of earnings within the App Retailer.
However with Apple Podcasts, the corporate is utilizing the identical damaged star rating system that uplifts scammers for its personal profit as effectively. And it’s a crystal clear instance of why you may’t belief star scores — as a result of everybody is aware of this was a 1.8-star app simply final month with many valid lingering complaints, and nothing’s basically modified. It’s the very same app immediately because it was then.