17.3 C
Thursday, May 30, 2024

Will heat pumps become illegal? Bosak and Mentzen manipulate

Must read

- Advertisement -

The changes proposed in the European Parliament will make heat pumps “illegal”, argue Krzysztof Bosak and Sławomir Mentzen. The European Parliament and industry representatives deny this message.

“Bosak & Mentzen, episode 11 Sławomir Mentzen: What has the EU invented for us again and what does it want to ban? There is another news, we are to have an amendment to the regulation on fluorinated gases and they will become illegal – you won’t believe … heat pumps!” – we read in an entry published on April 9 on the Konfederacja Twitter profile (original spelling of all entries). A short video was attached to the tweet. These are edited fragments of a conversation between two Confederation politicians: Krzysztof Bosak and Sławomir Mentzen. In the recording studio, they talk about the future of heat pump users.

Misleading tweet on the Konfederacja profileTwitter

In the next tweet in the thread, a link was made to the eleventh episode of the online program entitled “Bosak & Mentzen”. This published on YouTube on April 6 and the fragments of the conversation attached to the entry come from it. Two politicians deal with heat pumps in one of the first topics. Mentzen begins: “We’re going to have a revision of the F-Gas Ordinance and it will become illegal in a few years, probably from 2026 – you won’t believe it – heat pumps!”

- Advertisement -

Then Krzysztof Bosak took the floor: “Well, if anyone thought that only fossil fuels were targeted by the European Union, it turns out that not only. that photovoltaics and heat pumps, but it turns out that heat pumps are not safe either, because the environment committee of the European Parliament is proposing a total ban on these gases, which are used as gases as coolants in seventy percent of the heat pumps that are on the market And the idea of ​​the regulation is to just ban them altogether.”

He added: “Knowing life, it will turn out that one German company produces those without fluorine gases, the remaining thirty percent of the market. And the question is whether those who have already installed or are installing heat pumps will have to replace them just like at the moment, perhaps some people do not yet know that gas stoves will have to be removed, because they will already be based on fossil fuels, which is now out of fashion.

In response, Mentzen said: “I am less and less a happy owner of a heat pump. First, that my electricity bills have increased recently, and two, that I find out that I will probably have to replace this heat pump with something else. And now the question for what and who will give me a guarantee that the new thing I buy will not become illegal again in three years’ time.

This episode on YouTube has been viewed almost 190,000 times. times, and 17 thousand. users liked it.

Earlier, on April 5, Konfederacja’s Twitter account also featured an entry dedicated to heat pumps. We read in him: “The EU hits heat pumps!! The EP Environment Committee proposes a total ban on the use of fluorinated gases, which are used in heat pumps as a coolant. Experts warn that this could turn upside down as much as 70% of the heat pump market.”

The tweet is accompanied by a graphic signed with the Confederation logo. It shows the content published in the tweet, and the following statements are added below: “They are banning coal stoves, then gas stoves, and now they are phasing out heat pumps! Stop EU eco-madness!”

The Confederation manipulates the message about heat pumpsTwitter

Next in the Twitter thread we read: “All thanks to the amendment of the regulation of 2015 on the use of the so-called F-gases. As a result of the update, a ban on the use and sale of fluorinated gases, which are commonly used in this type of equipment, may be introduced. The European Commission proposes to introduce a total ban on the use and sale F-gases in some cases from 2026!”.

Then it was stated that “heat pumps, so far promoted in the EU climate policy as an alternative to heating with coal, wood, diesel oil or gas, may be withdrawn from use”, and the users of heat pumps “is another, after the users of gas stoves, deceived group that suffered installation costs of EU-promoted devices, and now she will have to give them up.

“Choices for the rich, orders for the poor. This is how the union works” vs. “Confedereshuria manipulates again”

The claims of Bosak and Mentzen, as well as the earlier Twitter thread of the Confederation, aroused numerous reactions from Internet users. “And good. The sooner it falls over its own feet, the better”; “The ban on gas stoves, now this. A few more years of leftism and we’ll warm ourselves by the fires, or there will be an order to wear sheepskin coats at home in winter”; “Choices for the rich, orders for the poor. This is how the union works”; “I read and I actually don’t believe… Heat pumps will become as illegal as petrol became illegal when leaded petrol was phased out,” some tweeted.

Not everyone believed the Confederation’s message: “And why these insinuations and understatements? You are just another party of swindlers and frauds?”; “Meritorics at the level of children”; “Heat pumps are fake as worms”; “The Konfedereshuria is manipulating again, this time threatening the collapse of the heat pump market. Meanwhile, the heat pump industry itself does not see the proposed regulations as a major problem!”.

Marek Józefiak, spokesman for Greenpeace Polska, also replied to the Confederation’s tweet with a fragment of the “Bosak & Mentzen” program. April 9 he tweeted: “You better take care of these divorce bans. Of course, heat pumps will not become illegal, only refrigerants will change. Entrepreneurs you supposedly listen to must straighten your fakes” and added the link to the material entitled “The EU ban on f-gases will not affect the service of currently sold heat pumps”.

What are the proposed changes that are being worked on in the European Parliament? Could heat pumps really be banned as a result of these proposals in a few years?

Industry representatives: “EU ban on f-gases will not affect the service of currently sold heat pumps”

On April 6, Paweł Lachman, president of the board of the Polish Organization for the Development of Heat Pump Technology (PORT PC), also reacted to the information provided on Twitter by the Confederation. PORT PC is an association of people associated with the heat pump industry.

“Neither the EC nor the EP plan to overturn the entire heat pump market, there will also be no problem with servicing heat pumps in the future” – he wrote Lachman, sharing the Konfederacja tweet with an illustration of heat pumps described above. In the same entry, he addresses his organization’s position on expected changes to the F-Gas Regulation. This is the same material that was shared by the Greenpeace Polska spokesperson under another Confederation entry.

Tweet of the CEO of PORT PCTwitter

“Expected changes in the f-gas regulation they do not provide for a service ban or any other restrictions on the use of heat pumps with synthetic refrigerants (Editor’s bold). All heat pumps that are currently on sale in Poland and will be available on our market in the coming years can be serviced without any obstacles throughout their lifetime. Restrictions on servicing, which have been proposed in connection with the amendment of the f-gas regulation, apply to other groups of refrigeration devices than heat pumps or refrigerants that are not used in heat pumps sold in Poland.

European Parliament: “what is already installed does not need to be replaced”

On March 30 this year, the European Parliament in plenary voted out its position on the F-Gas Regulation (i.e. concerning fluorinated greenhouse gases – ed.) by 426 votes in favour, 109 against and 52 abstentions. Thus, this is not just a proposal discussed in the Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI), but a position that the EP will enter into negotiations with the Council of the European Union in order to finalize the legal regulation.

In the outvoted document there is a timeline for the phase-down of F-gases for different sectors, of which for heat pumps it is in Annex IV, Amendment 145 (p. 70). Points 17-18 apply to heat pumps.

According to these points, January 1, 2025 is the proposed date of withdrawal from the market, among others “heat pumps that contain fluorinated greenhouse gases with a GWP of 150 or more” and “split heat pumps” containing less than 3 kg of fluorinated greenhouse gases. On January 1, 2027, another two types of heat pump systems would be phased out.

We asked the EP press office about the fate of heat pumps and their users in the face of changes prepared in the European Parliament.

“What these terms actually mean are the dates after which different types of equipment can no longer be placed on the EU market – these are situations where products are sold/made available for the first time in the EU. Parliament’s position allows for a period of 6 months after these dates (AM 74) the possibility of further distribution of products already placed on the market before the deadlines (i.e. already in warehouses, etc.). Thus, these are new products containing F-gases. This means that after these dates you can only sell heat pumps with natural refrigerants,” explains the EP press office.

He adds: “Products already installed (containing F-Gas) can still be serviced during their lifetime – well, at least until 2050, when it is proposed to completely phase out the sale of F-Gas (the same logic applies to all other products).”

The regulation will affect new products (editor’s bold) that will be sold – these will not be allowed to contain f-gases. But what is already installed does not need to be replaced. If the refrigerant circuit breaks down in the future, say more than 20 years later (…) – yes, in theory, they will have to be replaced, because f-gases will no longer be available,” concluded the EP press office.

The arrangements approved at the end of March are not final and do not constitute binding law. The EP press office stresses that “Parliament now has to negotiate the final text with member states before it becomes law”.

Author:Gabriela Sieczkowska

Main photo source: East News/Twitter

Source link

More articles

- Advertisement -

Latest article